Skip to content
Sunday, November 15, 2026
RiverHub Hub

A Proposal to Reform the Academy System and Assist Youth Talent

Among the favourite moments from this season came the other day, watching a promising talent surge forward from his defensive 18-yard line to net a winning finish.

Homegrown talents are invariably cherished by their club's followers and, judging by early glimpses, the supporters are going to witness many more remarkable moments from him in the time to come.

However, for every success story, there are numerous of other youngsters who are not successful past the myriad phases, and are forced to face a shattering disappointment at a tender age.

It is this group who fall away of youth football that are my focus, because I don't think the existing setup does enough to inform them about their chances, or support them when they are let go.

It needs an reform and, when I retired, I authored my own analysis into the academy system, with proposals for how it could be improved.

A Massive Investment – Yielding Certain Substantial Rewards

The viewpoint on academies is more than as a former manager. I have grandchildren are in the system, so I've got a direct interest too.

For all aspiring footballers, the aspiration of becoming a pro player is a special one. The youth development framework has been put in place to give them the optimal chance to achieve that ambition, with a specific programme being introduced over a decade ago.

Right now, thousands of young players are in the setup, at clubs from the highest division down. It's an all-encompassing structure, with training at least three nights a week and a fixtures schedule that takes up most of their weekends.

The same model is now being applied by the rapidly expanding sport, girls football, too.

These setups are resourced at exceptional levels and offer work for trainers, physiotherapists, medical staff and many more backroom staff.

The infrastructure are of the best standard, with excellent indoor and outdoor fields. Academic study is included too, with tutors hired to run mandatory vocational programmes.

The investment is vast but, as we have witnessed, the teams at the pinnacle are securing major benefits on that spending through temporary transfers and transfers of the young players.

What is the status of the Present Plan?

The main performance plan has been in place for around 15 years now, so how has it stood up to the scrutiny of time?

Academies now run a foundation programme for kids from the age of six, so if any of them finish the entire programme they would complete at 21. That's more time than a child spends in compulsory education, and spans his whole childhood.

These youngsters are provided with team uniform and coats, all emblazoned up, and are seen by friends and family as being part of that club.

Their identity has, in essence, been etched on them at a tender age and they also have to make a full commitment to the academy programme.

That means training on three evenings a week, and a games schedule occupying most of the weekend, are now part of a youngster's journey to chase his ambition.

From my findings, in a lot of cases what happens at their studies is seen as being less important, with the academy taking over and becoming the main concern of the child and his family's life.

A number of families see a big payday at the end of the rainbow if their child becomes a professional and heap tremendous pressure on their backs to make it.

Regrettably, statistics show the system has a complete mismatch of achievement and failure. We all see the stars, but we seldom acknowledge those who fail.

We Must Be Realistic About Their Prospects

I don't want to strip those dreams away from young players but we must be realistic with them about their chances.

While there are particular talents a club will identify as being future professionals, the truth is a large number of the boys have only been on the programme to fill the spots needed for coaching and the weekend games at each age group.

I really don't feel academies adequately set the understandings of these players or guardians, about where they stand in the wider structure.

Players and parents need to be given a full assessment of where they rate, so they can prepare for the likely disappointment when it arrives.

Our academies have developed some fantastic talent and there is greater attention paid to player wellbeing now than in the past, but let's also introduce a bit more emphasis on openness too.

Greater Focus on Academics

As I noted above, I feel many youngsters joining academies often take more notice of their trainers at times than they do of their educators.

It's important this is understood within the academy system, and youth managers impart this principle to the coaches at all age group.

This situation itself is nothing new. Tutelage played a significant part in my development, and sports teachers and coaches were always held in high regard.

But, for those running an academy, they must guarantee the coaches are given unambiguous guidance and awareness of their role because of the influence they have.

Standards of decorum, conduct and dedication should be as demanding as they are in any school environment – and should relate to the educational side of the child's life there too.

The framework I have put forward would have greater emphasis on studies and guidance – for families as well as the youth players – and also planning for what comes next if they are released aged 16.

The Plan to Help Youth Players

I would organise academies within several zones, each run by a director and link them with partner schools and colleges.

Before they get to apprenticeship level, players would be reviewed at 14 to see what academic track suits them.

At 16, players taking scholarships would begin in a mandatory combined academic programme with the academic partners.

Simultaneously, the players who are let go at 16, can commence a full-on combined educational programme with the schools or colleges.

The benefit for them would be the creation of a fresh games programme where the schools and colleges would

By

Joseph Vasquez

Lena Visser is a Dutch waterway expert with over 10 years of experience navigating the canals and rivers of the Netherlands.

RiverHub Hub

Type to search articles.